Publish nothing derived from today's printed parts
Decided with Cansin on 2026-11-02, #640, on #618’s licence research (its 2026-11-02 note in docs/research). Amends ADR 0008 (the viewer is off the site) and ADR 0009 (CI builds the pictures and GLBs no more). Amended 2026-11-02 (#649, Cansin): the Next Mech, clean-room, is published as soon as its pieces exist. CI’s
Blenderjob renders its panels and a picture per part (just pictures next) and bakes its GLB (just web next-mech) when what they are made from changed; the site serves them at /images and /viewer (Model > Pictures, Viewer), updated on every merge to main; a PR that changes them gets a before/after panel, the live site’s above its own, as thepreviewartifact (just preview <pr>). Every name published startsnext-, and tests hold what is rendered, baked, uploaded and served to the Next Mech’s documents, which carry none of today’s printed parts (test_workflows.py, test_site.py, site.test.mjs). Today’s Mech stays unpublished. Amended 2026-11-02 (#656, Cansin): the Next Mech in motion too, its eye gimbal’s sweep, blink and wink as looping WebPs (next-eyes-<motion>.webp,just pictures next) on Pictures, and a PR’s preview stacks each motion it changed, the live one above its own. Amended 2026-11-02 (#673, Cansin): no PR preview any more, it arrived too late to be useful: no before/after, nopreviewartifact orjust preview, no sticky comment and nopr-previewspre-release (deleted). A PR still renders and bakes the next Mech when its inputs changed, for Checks to test the site with; main publishes them. Amended 2026-11-02 (#663, Cansin): the motions the Next Mech plays in MuJoCo, its gestures and Rest, join the sweep asnext-eyes-<motion>.webp(Rest’s blink and the wink gesture in place of the keyed blink and wink) and as clips of its GLB. Amended 2026-11-02 (#642): the Next Mech’s documents are its two Base candidates,next-mech-aandnext-mech-b(just web next), each published asnext-mechwas. Amended 2026-11-02 (#686): its three head variants,next-mech-back,next-mech-crownandnext-mech-split, in place of the Base candidates. Amended 2026-11-02 (#712):next-mech-backalone, Cansin’s pick; Crown and Split are gone. Amended 2026-11-02 (#704, ADR 0020):next-mech-back-plainbeside it, Back with its Skeleton plain. Amended 2026-11-03 (#805, ADR 0022):-plainrenamed-mechanical, the Skeleton’s value. Amended 2026-11-03 (#839, Cansin): stills alone: nonext-eyes-<motion>.webpor other motion picture; the Next Mech moves in the web viewer alone (ADR 0008), which Pictures embeds per motion. Checks renders the pictures in eightRendershards, each picture dealt by its measured Blender seconds (model/shards.py), and Release’s manual run looks up the pictures and sim reports cached for the same inputs as a push’s run does; the weekly run still renders everything. Superseded in part 2026-11-04 (#894, ADR 0024): its publishing rules go with today’s Mech (thenext-names and guard, today’s Mech shown nowhere); the licence rule stays, restated there: never the designer’s geometry or dimensions.
Today’s printed parts follow the designer’s three models, whose licence forbids sharing or hosting “any other
derivative work of this object in its digital or physical format”. So nothing public shows or carries their geometry
until the clean-room Mech (#51) replaces them: the site has no pictures, hero, panels or viewer (its page, its GLBs, the
favicon render), the README no hero, a release’s docs no GLBs, and CI uploads no artifact with a mesh, an STL, a
picture or a GLB (the parts’ cut passes between jobs in the Actions cache, which nobody outside the repo’s workflows
can read). CI still builds and tests the model, the sim and its reports; the reports are numbers and MJCF that names
mesh files without carrying them, so /reports stays. The render and viewer code stays in the repo and runs locally
(just render, just hero, just web); CI no longer runs Blender. The parts’ source in model/printed stays public
until #51 deletes it, and history is not rewritten.
Considered options
Section titled “Considered options”- Ask the designer for permission: her Exclusive programme bars her from allowing it elsewhere (the research, section 6).
- Keep rendering in CI without publishing: on a public repo every artifact is downloadable, and pictures nobody can see only cost CI minutes.
noggin v0.2.26-6-g09bf9b7 · 09bf9b7